Sterilization indicators: how to monitor an autoclave
Steam sterilization needs steam, pressure, temperature and time. You check each load three ways: mechanical readings (time, temperature, pressure), chemical indicators (outside tape shows a pack was processed, an internal indicator shows steam got inside), and biological indicators (spore tests, at least weekly), the only check that directly measures killing power.
How steam sterilization works: time, temperature and saturated steam
An autoclave sterilizes by putting every item in direct contact with steam at the right temperature and pressure for a set time. The CDC names four parameters: steam, pressure, temperature and time. Pressure matters because it is how the chamber reaches temperatures high enough to kill microbes quickly.[1]
Moist heat kills by permanently coagulating and denaturing the enzymes and structural proteins of microorganisms. The ideal steam is dry saturated steam with a dryness fraction of 97% or more. Air left in the chamber or load gets in the way of steam contact, so removing air is part of every cycle.[1]
Recognized minimum exposure times for wrapped supplies[1]
Sterilizer type
Temperature
Minimum exposure
Gravity displacement
121°C (250°F)
30 minutes
Prevacuum
132°C (270°F)
4 minutes
Gravity displacement vs prevacuum autoclaves
In a gravity displacement autoclave, steam enters at the top or sides. Steam is lighter than air, so it pushes the air down and out through the drain. Some air can stay in the load, which slows steam penetration into porous items.[1]
A prevacuum autoclave uses a vacuum pump or ejector to pull air out before steam goes in, so steam penetrates porous loads almost at once. Because it relies on that air removal, a prevacuum autoclave needs a daily air-removal test (the Bowie-Dick test), run in an empty chamber.[1],[2]
The three types of sterilization monitoring
No single check proves a load is sterile. You combine mechanical, chemical and biological monitoring, and each one answers a different question.[2],[3]
Cycle time, temperature and pressure from the chart, printout, gauges or display
During the cycle
Chemical
Color change in heat or chemical sensitive ink when set conditions are reached
When the cycle is complete
Biological
Whether known resistant spores were killed
After incubation
Mechanical monitoring: reading the printout and gauges
Mechanical monitoring means looking at the gauges, display, chart or printout and noting time, temperature and pressure for every load. For steam, the CDC describes a daily review of cycle time and temperature on the record chart or printout, plus pressure on the gauge.[2],[3],[4]
Correct readings do not prove sterility, but wrong readings can be the first sign of a problem. If the readings show the autoclave did not reach the required time, temperature or pressure, do not use the packs from that load.[3],[4]
Chemical indicator types: outside tape vs inside the pack
Chemical indicators use heat or chemical sensitive inks that change color when certain sterilization conditions are present. They are cheap and give a result as soon as the cycle ends, but they only show exposure to the process. They do not prove sterilization was achieved.[2],[4]
External indicators, such as indicator tape or special markings on the outside of a package, show that the package went through a cycle. That is all they show. An internal indicator goes inside every package to show that the sterilant actually got through to the instruments. If the internal indicator cannot be seen from outside, use an external one as well.[2],[3],[4]
Internal indicators come in two kinds. A single-parameter indicator reports on only one condition, such as time or temperature. A multiparameter indicator is designed to react to two or more, such as time, temperature and the presence of steam.[4]
Check the indicator as soon as you take a package out of the autoclave. If either the internal or external indicator suggests poor processing, do not use the item.[2],[3]
Biological indicators: how spore tests work
A biological indicator, or spore test, holds highly resistant bacterial spores. It is the only process indicator that directly measures how well a cycle kills microorganisms, which is why it is the most accepted method of monitoring. For steam, the spores are Geobacillus stearothermophilus, incubated at 55 to 60°C after the cycle.[2],[4]
Run a spore test at least weekly, and in every load that contains an implant. Ideally, hold implants until the spore test comes back negative. Busy autoclaves can be tested daily to catch faults sooner.[2],[3]
Each test uses a matching control: an indicator from the same lot that is not put through the cycle but is incubated alongside the test. The control should grow, because that proves the spores were alive and the incubator worked. Growth in the processed test indicator is a positive result.[2],[3],[4]
What a failed biological indicator means
A positive spore test means spores survived the cycle. If mechanical and chemical indicators looked normal, a single positive result probably does not mean the autoclave is broken, but it still has to be followed up.[3]
CDC's dental guidance says to take the autoclave out of service, review your sterilization procedures, and repeat the spore test right away using the same cycle.[3]
CDC's protocol for hospital steam sterilizers asks for more: repeat the spore test in three consecutive cycles, and return the autoclave to service only if all three are negative.[5]
Recall and quarantine any implants from the load until they are shown to be sterile. Other items do not always need recall.[3]
If the repeat testing is also positive, the autoclave stays out of use until it is inspected or repaired and then passes spore tests in three consecutive cycles. Where possible, recall and re-sterilize items from suspect loads back to the last negative spore test.[2],[3]
These checks come from CDC guidance written for hospitals and dental offices, which is why implants and dental settings appear in it.[2],[3]
Ethylene oxide and gas plasma use their own indicators
Low temperature methods are monitored with their own biological indicators. Ethylene oxide uses Bacillus atrophaeus spores, and hydrogen peroxide gas plasma uses Geobacillus stearothermophilus spores. Mechanical monitors in clinical ethylene oxide units cannot measure gas concentration or humidity. For these methods, the CDC advises treating any positive spore test as a sterilizer malfunction.[2]
Worked examples
Example 1: A short cycle on the morning printout
You run a load of wrapped feline neuter packs in a gravity displacement autoclave. The printout shows the chamber held 121°C for 22 minutes, and the tape on every pack has changed color.
1Step 1: Find the standard: at 121°C in a gravity displacement sterilizer, wrapped supplies need at least 30 minutes.[1]
2Step 2: Compare: 22 minutes is short of 30, so the mechanical reading shows the cycle did not meet the required time.[1],[3]
3Step 3: Weigh the tape: external tape only shows the packs went through a cycle, not that they are sterile.[2]
Answer
Do not use the packs; reprocess them. A failed mechanical reading means the load cannot be trusted, and changed tape does not outweigh it.[1],[2],[3],[4]
Example 2: Does this pouch need tape?
You are packaging a single instrument for a cat spay in a peel pouch with a clear plastic face. A multiparameter strip goes inside, and you can read it through the plastic. A coworker asks whether the pouch also needs indicator tape.
1Step 1: Every package gets an internal indicator, to show the sterilant reached the instrument inside.[3],[4]
2Step 2: An external indicator is needed as well only when the internal one cannot be seen from outside.[3],[4]
3Step 3: Here the strip is visible through the clear face, so it does both jobs.[3],[4]
4Step 4: When the cycle ends, check the strip as soon as you take the pouch out.[3]
Answer
No tape is needed for this pouch, because the internal strip can be read from outside. A wrapped pack that hides its internal indicator would need an external one too.[3],[4]
Example 3: A spore test control that did not grow
On Friday you read the weekly spore test from the autoclave. The processed vial shows no growth, but the control vial from the same lot also shows no growth.
1Step 1: The control was never put through the cycle, so it should grow. Its growth is what shows the spores were alive and the incubator worked.[2],[4]
2Step 2: No growth in the control means neither of those was confirmed.[2]
3Step 3: So the clear processed vial tells you nothing about whether the cycle killed the spores.[2],[4]
Answer
You cannot count this as a passing spore test. The control has to grow before a clear processed vial means anything, so the test needs repeating.[2],[4]
Common mistakes
XTreating changed indicator tape as proof of sterility: external indicators only show that a package was processed.[2],[4]
XReading growth in the control vial as a failure: the unexposed control is meant to grow, and only growth in the processed indicator is positive.[2],[3]
XAssuming normal time and temperature readings prove a load is sterile: correct mechanical readings do not ensure sterilization.[4]
XRunning spore tests only monthly: the CDC says at least weekly, and in every load that contains an implant.[2],[3]
XAssuming ethylene oxide uses the same spores as steam: ethylene oxide is monitored with Bacillus atrophaeus, steam with Geobacillus stearothermophilus.[2]